Elliot Junction rail accident
Elliot Junction rail crash | |
---|---|
Elliot Junction site, looking north-east | |
Details | |
Date | 28 December 1906 15:30 (approx.) [1] |
Location | Elliot Junction station, Forfarshire |
Country | Scotland |
Line | Edinburgh to Aberdeen Line |
Incident type | Collision |
Cause | Driver error [1] |
Statistics | |
Trains | 2 |
Deaths | 22 [1] |
Injured | 24(16 minor 8 serious) [1] |
List of UK rail accidents by year |
The Elliot Junction rail accident[a] occurred on 28 December 1906 at Elliot Junction in Forfarshire (now Angus), Scotland. An express hit the rear of a local passenger train, which was just moving off from the station, killing 22 and injuring 24. The immediate cause was driver error, but a snow blizzard had disrupted services, and the driver received only a light sentence.
Background
The accident happened during a severe blizzard on 28 December[b] 1906 at Elliot Junction station in Forfarshire, Scotland. Now shut, this was situated between the present-day stations of Carnoustie and Arbroath, being closest to the latter, one and a half miles away. In terms of lives lost, the accident was the 10th worst in British railway history up until that point, with 22 fatalities. An additional 8 persons were severely hurt and 16 received minor injuries.[1]
The official inquiry found the driver of one of the trains involved, named Gourlay, to be largely responsible for the tragedy.[1] He was subsequently convicted of culpable homicide and sentenced to 5 months in prison,[2] later reduced to a term of 3 months.[3] The relatively light sentence reflected the opinion of the jury that other factors had played an equal, if not more important role in the accident.[2] Whilst not completely exonerating the driver, a more recent analysis drew attention to the extreme weather and highlighted a number of organizational failures which contributed to the disaster.[4]
The Accident
At around 3.30 p.m., a North British Railway express hit the rear of a local Dundee and Arbroath Railway passenger train, which had just stopped at Elliott Junction and was beginning to move off. Having left King's Cross, London at 11.30pm the previous day, the express departed Edinburgh Waverley for Aberdeen at 7.35 a.m., but due to heavy snowfall over the previous two days had been unable to progress further than Arbroath, where it was due at 9.40am.[5] At the time of the crash it was heading back to Dundee with passengers still on board.[6][7]
Among the casualties was the Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) Alexander William Black, who was severely injured in the crash and died shortly thereafter.[8]
The Inquiry
The Board of Trade Inquiry placed primary responsibility on the driver of one of the trains who had "failed to heed instructions to drive with caution".[9] It also discussed the role of alcohol and said that "the proximity of the Victoria Bar to the up platform is a very undesirable feature in the surroundings of Arbroath station. The substitution of a coffee shop and refreshment room would be greatly in the general interests of the staff".[1]
See also
Notes
- ^ The majority of contemporary newspaper reports referred to the incident as the "Arbroath railway disaster".
- ^ Coincidentally, this was the anniversary of the nearby Tay Bridge disaster (1879).
References
- ^ a b c d e f g Pringle, J. W. (26 February 1907). Dundee and Arbroath Joint Railway (PDF) (Report). London: His Majesty's Stationery Office. Retrieved 21 December 2020.
- ^ a b "The Arbroath Railway Accident". The Times. London. 13 March 1907. p. 7.
- ^ "The Sentence of Gourlay". The Times. London. 1 April 1907. p. 8.
- ^ Rolt, L. T. C.; Kichenside, G. (1982). Red for Danger: A History of Railway Accidents and Railway Safety (4th ed.). Newton Abbot: David & Charles. pp. 121–124. ISBN 0715383620.
- ^ Sekon, G. A., ed. (February 1907). "What Our Railways Are Doing". The Railway Magazine. Vol. 20, no. 116. p. 172.
- ^ "Terrible Railway Disaster near Arbroath". The Edinburgh Evening News. 29 December 1906. p. 6.
- ^ "The Arbroath Disaster". The Leeds and Yorkshire Mercury. 31 December 1906. p. 5.
- ^ "The Railway Accident in Scotland". The Times. London. 31 December 1906. p. 9.
- ^ http://danger-ahead.railfan.net/gallery/elliot_jct.html Gallery - Elliot Junction 1906
External links
- Image of local train carriage after the express had run into the back of it
- v
- t
- e
- Slough (Jun 1900)
- Glasgow St Enoch (Jul 1903)
- Gomshall (Feb 1904)
- Hall Road (Jul 1905) ‡
- Witham (Sep 1905)
- Charing Cross (Dec 1905)
- Salisbury (Jul 1906) ‡
- Grantham (Sep 1906)
- Elliot Junction (Dec 1906) ‡
- Newport (Sep 1907)
- Birmingham (Oct 1907)
- Dore (Oct 1907)
- Shrewsbury (Oct 1907)
- Bournemouth (May 1908)
- Tonbridge (Mar 1909)
- Braunton Road (Jan 1910)
- Coulsdon North (Jan 1910)
- Hawes Junction (Dec 1910)
- Pontypridd (Jan 1911)
- Ditton Junction (Sep 1912)
- Chumhill (Feb 1913)
- Ais Gill (Sep 1913)
- Burntisland (Apr 1914)
- Carrbridge (Jun 1914)
- Ilford (Jan 1915)
- Quintinshill (May 1915) ‡ §
- Weedon (Aug 1915)
- St Bedes Junction (Dec 1915)
- Penistone (Feb 1916)
- Ratho (Jan 1917)
- Bere Ferrers (Sep 1917)
- Little Salkeld (Jan 1918)
- Paddock Wood (May 1919)
- Littlehampton (Aug 1920)
- Abermule (Jan 1921)
- Birmingham New Street (Nov 1921)
- Birkenhead Park (Dec 1922)
- Retford (Feb 1923)
- Lytham (Nov 1924)
- Parkgate & Rawmarsh (Nov 1926)
- Hull Paragon (Feb 1927)
- Penistone (Feb 1927)
- Sevenoaks (Aug 1927)
- Darlington (Jun 1928) ‡
- London Bridge (Jul 1928)
- Glasgow Queen Street (Oct 1928)
- Charfield (Oct 1928)
- Combe Down Tunnel (Nov 1929)
- Lawrence Hill (Jan 1930)
- Leighton Buzzard (Mar 1931)
- Raynes Park (May 1933)
- Winwick (Sep 1934)
- Welwyn Garden City (Jun 1935)
- Battersea Park (Apr 1937)
- Castlecary (Dec 1937) ‡
- Charing Cross (Mar 1938)
- Charing Cross (May 1938)
- Bounds Green (Oct 1940)
- Balham (Oct 1940) ‡
- Norton Fitzwarren (Nov 1940) ‡
- Bank (Jan 1941) ‡
- Eccles (Dec 1941) ‡
- Bethnal Green (Mar 1943) ‡
- Catterick Bridge (Feb 1944)
- Ilford (Jan 1944)
- Soham (Jun 1944)
- Ballymacarrett (Jan 1945) ‡
- King's Cross (Feb 1945)
- Bourne End (Sep 1945) ‡
- Lichfield (Jan 1946) ‡
- Potters Bar (Feb 1946)
- Grayrigg (May 1947)
- Polesworth (July 1947)
- Doncaster (Aug 1947)
- South Croydon (Oct 1947) ‡
- Goswick (Oct 1947) ‡
- Manchester Victoria (Dec 1947)
- Winsford (Apr 1948) ‡
- Stockport Viaduct (Nov 1948)
- Penmanshiel Tunnel (Jun 1949)
- Penmaenmawr (Aug 1950)
- Doncaster (Mar 1951)
- Huntingdon (Jul 1951)
- Newcastle (Aug 1951)
- Weedon (Sep 1951)
- Harrow & Wealdstone (Oct 1952) ‡
- Stratford (Apr 1953)
- Irk Valley Junction (Aug 1953)
- Watford Junction (Feb 1954)
- Sutton Coldfield (Jan 1955)
- Milton (Nov 1955)
- Barnes (Dec 1955)
- Luton (Dec 1955)
- Welwyn Garden City (Jan 1957)
- Chapel-en-le-Frith (Feb 1957)
- Lewisham (Dec 1957) ‡
- Dagenham East (Jan 1958)
- Eastbourne (Aug 1958)
- Settle (Jan 1960)
- Severn Railway Bridge (Oct 1960)
- Royton (Feb 1961)
- Baschurch (Feb 1961)
- Singleton Bank (Jul 1961)
- Lincoln (Jun 1962)
- Coppenhall Junction (Dec 1962)
- Knowle & Dorridge (Aug 1963)
- Cheadle Hulme (May 1964)
- Coton Hill (Jan 1965)
- Winsford (Jun 1965)
- Stechford (Feb 1967)
- Connington South (Mar 1967)
- Thirsk (Jul 1967)
- Hither Green (Nov 1967) ‡
- Hixon (Jan 1968)
- Castlecary (Sep 1968)
- Marden (Jan 1969)
- Morpeth (May 1969)
- Audenshaw Junction (May 1970)
- Sheerness-on-Sea (Feb 1971)
- Chester General (May 1972)
- Eltham Well Hall (Jun 1972)
- King's Cross & Euston (Sep 1973)
- Ealing (Dec 1973)
- Watford Junction (Jan 1975)
- Moorgate (Feb 1975) ‡
- Nuneaton (Jun 1975)
- Green Park (Oct 1975)
- West Ham (Mar 1976)
- Taunton (Jul 1978)
- Paisley Gilmour Street (Apr 1979)
- Invergowrie (Oct 1979)
- Dunmurry (Jan 1980)
- Bushey (Feb 1980)
- Bushey (Apr 1980)
- Holborn (Jul 1980)
- Ulleskelf (Dec 1981)
- Seer Green (Dec 1981)
- Wrawby Junction (Dec 1983)
- Morpeth (Jun 1984)
- Polmont (Jul 1984)
- Wembley Central (Oct 1984)
- Oxford Circus (Nov 1984)
- Eccles (Dec 1984)
- Summit Tunnel (Dec 1984)
- Lockington (Jul 1986)
- Colwich (Sep 1986)
- Glanrhyd Bridge (Oct 1987)
- King's Cross (Nov 1987) ‡
- Clapham Junction (Dec 1988) ‡
- Purley (Mar 1989)
- Glasgow Bellgrove (Mar 1989)
- West Ealing (Aug 1989)
- Stafford (Aug 1990)
- Cannon Street (Jan 1991)
- Victoria & Paddington (Feb 1991)
- Newton (Jul 1991)
- Severn Tunnel (Dec 1991)
- London Bridge (Feb 1992)
- Morpeth (Nov 1992)
- Maidstone East (Sep 1993)
- Greenock (Jun 1994)
- Morpeth (Jun 1994)
- Cowden (Oct 1994)
- Ais Gill (Jan 1995)
- Largs (Jul 1995)
- Stafford (Mar 1996)
- Watford (Aug 1996)
- Channel Tunnel (Nov 1996)
- Bexley (Feb 1997)
- Southall (Sep 1997)
- Spa Road Junction (Jan 1999)
- Winsford (Jun 1999)
- Ladbroke Grove (Oct 1999) ‡
§ indicates the deadliest railway accident in British history
1815–1899 2000–present
56°32′47″N 2°37′01″W / 56.54639°N 2.61694°W / 56.54639; -2.61694