True Heart Susie
- June 1, 1919 (1919-06-01)
True Heart Susie is a 1919 American drama film directed by D. W. Griffith and starring Lillian Gish. A print of the film survives in the film archive of the British Film Institute.[1] The film has seen several VHS releases as well as a DVD issue.
Plot
As described in a film magazine,[2] "True Heart Susie" (Gish) lives with her aunt (O'Connor) and loves stupid William Jenkins (Harron). Her love is so great that she sacrifices the family cow, a pet of hers, and other farm produce so that he can go to college, but the benefaction is a secret one, and he finishes his theological studies without suspecting that she aided him. He has impressed her that she must dress as plainly as possible, and she is so attired when she goes with him for a "sody" on his triumphant return from college, but his eyes wander to girls giving a more attractive expression of themselves. After he becomes a minister, he cruelly consults Susie about the policy of taking a wife, and almost breaks her heart when he weds gay Bettina "Betty" Hopkins (Seymour), expecting his bride to adopt herself to his colorless life. The young wife fails to satisfy her husband with her cooking, with William finding the dishes Susie makes more to his taste. He begins to regret his marriage, and so does his wife, who escapes the monotony of her marriage by attending a dance at a neighboring house. After she loses her key and gets caught in the rain on the way home, Betty appeals to Susie, who shields her from the consequences as far as the minister is concerned. However, Betty's fright and her soaking bring on a fatal sickness, and it is after her death that her husband learns of her escapade. Although he swears never to marry again, he finds that True Heart Susie has given the one opportunity of his life, and he returns to her with the offering of his hand in marriage.[3][4][5]
Cast
- Lillian Gish as True Heart Susie
- Robert Harron as William Jenkins
- Clarine Seymour as Bettina Hopkins
- Kate Bruce as Bettina's aunt
- Raymond Cannon as Sporty Malone
- Carol Dempster as Bettina's friend
- George Fawcett as The Stranger
- Wilbur Higby as William's father
- Loyola O'Connor as Susie's aunt
Reception and critical assessment
“An outstanding performance from Lillian Gish elevates the character of Susie from the near-ridiculous to moments of the sublime…When she discovers William in the arms of Bettina, the restrained grief on her face and the tears that well up in her eyes during one long and continuous close-up contain the very essence of rejected devotion [producing] a scene which Miss Gish herself has rarely equaled. That smile, that shot, would alone justify the whole of Griffith’s work, for it embodies all that is Griffith and all that is Gish, and the two talents combine to produce a perfect cinematic (italics) whole. It is one of those extraordinary moments in the cinema.”—Film historian Paul O’Dell in Griffith and the Rise of Hollywood (1970)[6]
Film historian Paul O’Dell reports that “many commentators have noted the great charm of his picture, as well as moments of deep emotional intensity.”[7] Critic James Travers of French Films.org applies a number of superlatives to True Heart Suzie, noting its “authenticity” and “realism,” and praising Lillian Gish for her naturalistic portrayal of Suzie.[8]
Though filmed concurrently with Griffith’s Broken Blossoms (1919), True Heart Susie was released after the more highly acclaimed work which also starred Lillian Gish. As such, True Heart Suzie “is not, or has not been, more highly regarded than perhaps it should have been.”[9][10] TV Guide affirms the point:
True Heart Suzie, overshadowed by Broken Blossoms, is a modest little film that shows Griffith at his most Victorian, but he treats the antediluvian plot with absolute sincerity and simplicity, transcending the primitive melodramatic cliches and creating a kind of elemental emotional truth.[11]
Paul O’Dell adds:
In all of Griffith’s pictures there is a certain amount of unashamed sentimentality; in True Heart Susie there is more than in most...technically, the film has few pretensions, and it is for this reason it is successful as a work of art...It is in fact the end of the film that is the weakest. Susie matures into a woman during the course of the action—a recurring Griffith theme—but when William eventually proposes she lapses uncomfortably back to her girlish coyness which dominated the beginning of the film. [12][13]
Accolades
The film is recognized by American Film Institute in these lists:
- 2002: AFI's 100 Years...100 Passions – Nominated[14]
See also
- D. W. Griffith filmography
- Lillian Gish filmography
- The House That Shadows Built (1931 promotional film by Paramount)
References
- ^ "Progressive Silent Film List: True Heart Susie". Silent Era. Retrieved September 1, 2008.
- ^ Harrison, Louis Reeves (June 14, 1919). "Reviews and Advertising Aids: True Heart Susie". Moving Picture World. 40 (11). New York City: Chalmers Publishing Company: 1677, 1679. Retrieved September 22, 2014.
- ^ O’Dell, 1970 p. 119-122: Plot summary
- ^ Travers, 2009: Plot summary
- ^ TV Guide, 2000: Plot summary
- ^ O’Dell, 1970 p. 121
- ^ O’Dell, 1970 p. 121
- ^ Travers, 2009
- ^ O’Dell, 1970 p. 122-123
- ^ Travers, 2009: Travers acknowledges that Griffith’s handling of the picture was “modest” in its thematic aims.
- ^ T. V. Guide, 2000
- ^ O’Dell, 1970 p. 122
- ^ Travers, 2009: Travers notes the work’s “innocence” and “down-to-earth” qualities.
- ^ "AFI's 100 Years of Film Scores Nominees" (PDF). Retrieved August 20, 2016.
Sources
- O’Dell, Paul (1970). Griffith and the Rise of Hollywood (1970 ed.). New York: A. S. Barnes & Co. p. 163. ISBN 0-498-07718-7.
- "True Heart Susie Reviews". TV Guide. 2000. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
- Travers, James (2009). "True Heart Susie (1919)". French Films.org. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
External links
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/4/4a/Commons-logo.svg/30px-Commons-logo.svg.png)
- True Heart Susie at IMDb
- True Heart Susie at AllMovie
- True Heart Susie available for free download at Internet Archive
- v
- t
- e
- The Adventures of Dollie
- The Fight for Freedom
- The Tavern Keeper's Daughter
- The Black Viper
- The Red Man and the Child
- Deceived Slumming Party
- The Bandit's Waterloo
- A Calamitous Elopement
- The Greaser's Gauntlet
- The Man and the Woman
- The Fatal Hour
- For Love of Gold
- Balked at the Altar
- For a Wife's Honor
- Betrayed by a Handprint
- Monday Morning in a Coney Island Police Court
- The Girl and the Outlaw
- Behind the Scenes
- The Red Girl
- The Heart of O'Yama
- Where the Breakers Roar
- A Smoked Husband
- The Stolen Jewels
- The Devil
- The Zulu's Heart
- Father Gets in the Game
- Ingomar, the Barbarian
- The Vaquero's Vow
- The Planter's Wife
- Romance of a Jewess
- The Call of the Wild
- Concealing a Burglar
- After Many Years
- The Pirate's Gold
- The Taming of the Shrew
- The Guerrilla
- The Song of the Shirt
- The Ingrate
- A Woman's Way
- The Clubman and the Tramp
- Money Mad
- The Valet's Wife
- The Feud and the Turkey
- The Reckoning
- The Test of Friendship
- An Awful Moment
- The Christmas Burglars
- Mr. Jones at the Ball
- The Helping Hand
- One Touch of Nature
- The Maniac Cook
- Mrs. Jones Entertains
- The Honor of Thieves
- Love Finds a Way
- The Sacrifice
- A Rural Elopement
- Those Boys!
- The Criminal Hypnotist
- The Fascinating Mrs. Francis
- Mr. Jones Has a Card Party
- Those Awful Hats
- The Welcome Burglar
- The Cord of Life
- The Girls and Daddy
- The Brahma Diamond
- Edgar Allen Poe
- A Wreath in Time
- Tragic Love
- The Curtain Pole
- His Ward's Love
- The Joneses Have Amateur Theatricals
- The Hindoo Dagger
- The Politician's Love Story
- The Golden Louis
- At the Altar
- The Prussian Spy
- His Wife's Mother
- A Fool's Revenge
- The Wooden Leg
- The Roue's Heart
- The Salvation Army Lass
- The Lure of the Gown
- I Did It
- The Voice of the Violin
- The Deception
- And a Little Child Shall Lead Them
- A Burglar's Mistake
- The Medicine Bottle
- Jones and His New Neighbors
- A Drunkard's Reformation
- Trying to Get Arrested
- The Road to the Heart
- A Rude Hostess
- Schneider's Anti-Noise Crusade
- A Sound Sleeper
- Lady Helen's Escapade
- Lucky Jim
- Jones and the Lady Book Agent
- Resurrection
- Two Memories
- Eloping with Auntie
- The Cricket on the Hearth
- The Violin Maker of Cremona
- A New Trick
- The Lonely Villa
- The Son's Return
- Her First Biscuits
- The Country Doctor
- The Cardinal's Conspiracy
- Tender Hearts
- The Friend of the Family
- The Renunciation
- The Mended Lute
- The Sealed Room
- The Little Darling
- The Hessian Renegades
- Comata, the Sioux
- Getting Even
- In Old Kentucky
- Leather Stocking
- Pippa Passes or The Song of Conscience
- Fools of Fate
- His Lost Love
- The Gibson Goddess
- Nursing a Viper
- The Death Disc: A Story of the Cromwellian Period
- Through the Breakers
- The Red Man's View
- A Corner in Wheat
- A Trap for Santa Claus
- In Little Italy
- To Save Her Soul
- The Day After
- Choosing a Husband
- Bill Sharkey's Last Game
- The Rocky Road
- The Woman from Mellon's
- The Englishman and the Girl
- In Old California
- Faithful
- The Two Brothers
- As It Is In Life
- A Romance of the Western Hills
- The Unchanging Sea
- Ramona
- In the Season of Buds
- A Child of the Ghetto
- In the Border States
- What the Daisy Said
- A Flash of Light
- An Arcadian Maid
- The House with Closed Shutters
- Wilful Peggy
- The Modern Prodigal
- A Mohawk's Way
- The Oath and the Man
- Rose O'Salem-Town
- The Fugitive
- Winning Back His Love
- The Two Paths
- The Italian Barber
- His Trust
- His Trust Fulfilled
- Fate's Turning
- Heart Beats of Long Ago
- What Shall We Do with Our Old?
- Fisher Folks
- His Daughter
- The Lily of the Tenements
- A Decree of Destiny
- Was He a Coward?
- The Lonedale Operator
- The Spanish Gypsy
- The Broken Cross
- How She Triumphed
- The New Dress
- The Crooked Road
- The White Rose of the Wilds
- The Smile of a Child
- Enoch Arden: Part I
- Enoch Arden: Part II
- The Primal Call
- Fighting Blood
- The Indian Brothers
- A Country Cupid
- The Last Drop of Water
- Out from the Shadow
- The Blind Princess and the Poet
- Swords and Hearts
- The Stuff Heroes Are Made Of
- Her Awakening
- The Making of a Man
- The Adventures of Billy
- The Long Road
- Love in the Hills
- The Battle
- Through Darkened Vales
- The Miser's Heart
- A Woman Scorned
- The Voice of the Child
- The Eternal Mother
- The Old Bookkeeper
- For His Son
- The Transformation of Mike
- A Sister's Love
- Under Burning Skies
- The Sunbeam
- A String of Pearls
- The Girl and Her Trust
- The Root of Evil
- The Goddess of Sagebrush Gulch
- The Punishment
- The Female of the Species
- Just Like a Woman
- One Is Business, the Other Crime
- The Lesser Evil
- A Beast at Bay
- An Outcast Among Outcasts
- Home Folks
- A Temporary Truce
- The Spirit Awakened
- Man's Lust for Gold
- Man's Genesis
- The Sands of Dee
- The Narrow Road
- The Inner Circle
- A Change of Spirit
- An Unseen Enemy
- Blind Love
- The Massacre
- Two Daughters of Eve
- Friends
- So Near, yet So Far
- A Feud in the Kentucky Hills
- The Chief's Blanket
- In the Aisles of the Wild
- The One She Loved
- The Painted Lady
- The Musketeers of Pig Alley
- Heredity
- Gold and Glitter
- My Baby
- The Informer
- Brutality
- The New York Hat
- My Hero
- The Burglar's Dilemma
- A Cry for Help
- The God Within
- Three Friends
- The Telephone Girl and the Lady
- An Adventure in the Autumn Woods
- The Tender Hearted Boy
- A Misappropriated Turkey
- Brothers
- Oil and Water
- A Chance Deception
- Love in an Apartment Hotel
- Broken Ways
- A Girl's Stratagem
- The Unwelcome Guest
- Near to Earth
- Fate
- A Welcome Intruder
- The Sheriff's Baby
- The Hero of Little Italy
- The Little Tease
- A Misunderstood Boy
- The Left-Handed Man
- The Lady and the Mouse
- If We Only Knew
- The Wanderer
- The Stolen Loaf
- The House of Darkness
- The Yaqui Cur
- Just Gold
- The Ranchero's Revenge
- A Timely Interception
- Death's Marathon
- The Mothering Heart
- The Sorrowful Shore
- The Enemy's Baby
- The Mistake
- Two Men of the Desert (lost)
- Madonna of the Storm
- The Battle at Elderbush Gulch
- The Conscience of Hassan Bey
- Judith of Bethulia (1914)
- Battle of the Sexes (1914, lost)
- Brute Force (1914)
- Home, Sweet Home (1914)
- The Escape (1914, lost)
- The Avenging Conscience: or "Thou Shalt Not Kill" (1914)
- The Birth of a Nation (1915)
- Intolerance (1916)
- Hearts of the World (1918)
- The Great Love (1918, lost)
- Lillian Gish in a Liberty Loan Appeal (1918, lost)
- The Greatest Thing in Life (1918, lost)
- A Romance of Happy Valley (1919)
- The Girl Who Stayed at Home (1919)
- Broken Blossoms (1919)
- True Heart Susie (1919)
- Scarlet Days (1919)
- The Greatest Question (1919)
- The Idol Dancer (1920)
- Remodeling Her Husband (1920, lost)
- The Love Flower (1920)
- Way Down East (1920)
- Dream Street (1921)
- Orphans of the Storm (1921)
- One Exciting Night (1922)
- The White Rose (1923)
- America (1924)
- Isn't Life Wonderful (1924)
- Sally of the Sawdust (1925)
- That Royle Girl (1925, lost)
- The Sorrows of Satan (1926)
- Drums of Love (1928)
- The Battle of the Sexes (1928)
- Lady of the Pavements (1929)
- Abraham Lincoln (1930)
- The Struggle (1931)