- 1950
- - Aline Bernstein – Regina
- 1951
- - Miles White – Bless You All
- 1952
- - Irene Sharaff – The King and I
- 1953
- - Miles White – Hazel Flagg
- 1954
- - Richard Whorf – Ondine
- 1955
- - Cecil Beaton – Quadrille
- 1956
- - Alvin Colt – Pipe Dream
- Mainbocher – The Great Sebastians
- Alvin Colt – The Lark / Phoenix '55 / Pipe Dream
- Helene Pons – The Diary of Anne Frank / Heavenly Twins / A View from the Bridge
| - 1957
- - Cecil Beaton – My Fair Lady
- Cecil Beaton – Little Glass Clock / My Fair Lady
- Alvin Colt – Li'l Abner / The Sleeping Prince
- Dorothy Jeakins – Major Barbara / Too Late the Phalarope
- Irene Sharaff – Candide / Happy Hunting / Shangri La / Small War on Murray Hill
- 1958
- - Motley Theatre Design Group – The First Gentleman
- Lucinda Ballard – Orpheus Descending
- Motley Theatre Design Group – Look Back in Anger / Look Homeward, Angel / Shinbone Alley / The Country Wife / The First Gentleman
- Irene Sharaff – West Side Story
- Miles White – Jamaica / Time Remembered / Oh, Captain!
- 1959
- - Rouben Ter-Arutunian – Redhead
- Castillo – Goldilocks
- Dorothy Jeakins – The World of Suzie Wong
- Oliver Messel – Rashomon
- Irene Sharaff – Flower Drum Song
|