- 1910: William Nichols
- 1911: William Nichols
- 1912: Chester Nelson
- 1913: Chester Nelson
- 1914: William Nichols
- 1915: Chester Williams
- 1916: William Nichols
- 1917: Jock Collins
- 1918: Jock Taylor
- 1919: John Gatherum
- 1920: William Nichols
- 1921: Sandy Baxter
- 1922: Phil Hessler
- 1923: Bill Mehlhorn
- 1924: Bill Creavy
- 1925: Ed Dudley
- 1926: Ed Dudley
- 1927: Dick Grout
- 1928: Harold Long
- 1929: Dick Grout
- 1930: Clarence Clark
- 1931: Harold "Jug" McSpaden
- 1932: Jimmy Gullane
- 1933: Jimmy Gullane
- 1934: Harold "Jug" McSpaden
- 1935: Walter Emery
- 1936: Clarence Yockey
- 1937: Jack Malloy
- 1938: Billy Simpson
- 1939: Zell Eaton
- 1940: Billy Simpson
- 1941: Buddy Poteet
- 1942: George Whitehead
- 1943: Geen toernooi
- 1944: Geen toernooi
- 1945: Geen toernooi
- 1946: Raymond Gaford
- 1947: George Getchell
- 1948: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1949: Tex Consolver
| - 1950: Charles Klein
- 1951: Geen toernooi
- 1952: Geen toernooi
- 1953: Labron Harris
- 1954: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1955: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1956: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1957: Johnny Palmer
- 1958: Buster Cupit
- 1959: Joe Walser jr.
- 1960: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1961: Jimmy Gauntt
- 1962: Babe Hiskey
- 1963: Labron Harris jr.
- 1964: Jerry Pittman
- 1965: Buster Cupit
- 1966: Bob Dickson
- 1967: Jamie Gough III
- 1968: Grier Jones
- 1969: Chris Gers
- 1970: Chris Gers
- 1971: Bob Dickson
- 1972: Don Maddox
- 1973: Spike Kelley
- 1974: Bobby Stroble
- 1975: Danny Edwards
- 1976: Mark Hayes
- 1977: Danny Edwards
- 1978: Lindy Miller
- 1979: Danny Edwards
- 1980: Jaime Gonzales
- 1981: Gil Morgan
- 1982: Doug Tewell
- 1983: Tom Jones
- 1984: Kenny Huff
- 1985: Bob Tway
- 1986: Lindy Miller
- 1987: Bob Tway
- 1988: Mark Hayes
- 1989: Doug Martin
| - 1990: Willie Wood
- 1991: Jim Kane
- 1992: Bryan Norton
- 1993: Mark Hayes
- 1994: David Edwards
- 1995: Willie Wood
- 1996: David Edwards
- 1997: Gil Morgan
- 1998: Kevin Dillen
- 1999: Todd Hamilton
- 2000: John Bizik
- 2001: Lucas Glover
- 2002: Chris Noel
- 2003: Cody Freeman
- 2004: Rocky Walcher
- 2005: Kyle Willmann
- 2006: Kyle Flinton
- 2007: Rocky Walcher
- 2008: Brett Myers
- 2009: Robert Streb
- 2010: Rhein Gibson
- 2011: Robert Streb
- 2012: Matt VanCleave
- 2013: Chris Worrell (amateur)
|