- 1920: Tom Kerrigan
- 1921: Jack Dowling
- 1922: Willie Macfarlane
- 1923: George McLean
- 1924: Willie Macfarlane
- 1925: Mike Brady
- 1926: Johnny Farrell
- 1927: Bobby Cruickshank
- 1928: Bill Mehlhorn
- 1929: Bobby Cruickshank
- 1930: Willie Macfarlane
- 1931: Paul Runyan
- 1932: Tony Manero
- 1933: Mike Turnesa
- 1934: Paul Runyan
- 1935: Paul Runyan
- 1936: Paul Runyan
- 1937: Frank Moore
- 1938: Frank Moore
- 1939: Paul Runyan
- 1940: Ben Hogan
- 1941: Mike Turnesa
- 1942: Paul Runyan
- 1943: Geen toernooi (WO II)
- 1944: Geen toernooi (WO II)
- 1945: Geen toernooi (WO II)
- 1946: Claude Harmon
- 1947: Claude Harmon
- 1948: Tony Manero
- 1949: Jack Patroni
| - 1950: Claude Harmon
- 1951: Claude Harmon
- 1952: Fred Annon
- 1953: Claude Harmon
- 1954: Herman Barron
- 1955: Mickey Homa
- 1956: Mickey Homa
- 1957: Mickey Homa
- 1958: Fred Annon
- 1959: Robert Watson
- 1960: Claude Harmon
- 1961: Doug Ford
- 1962: Gil Cavanaugh & Roger Ginsberg (a)
- 1963: Doug Ford
- 1964: Terry Wilcox
- 1965: Terry Wilcox
- 1966: Frank Wharton
- 1967: Roy Pace
- 1968: Denny Lyons (a)
- 1969: Mike Krak
- 1970: John Buczek
- 1971: David Ragaini (a)
- 1972: Don Massengale
- 1973: John Gentile
- 1974: Kelley Moser
- 1975: John Gentile
- 1976: John Ruby
- 1977: Tom Joyce
- 1978: John Gentile
- 1979: John Gentile
| - 1980: Gene Borek
- 1981: Bobby Heins
- 1982: Bobby Heins
- 1983: Bobby Heins
- 1984: Bruce Douglass
- 1985: Evan Schiller
- 1986: Bill Britton
- 1987: Mike White
- 1988: Bobby Heins
- 1989: Ron McDougal
- 1990: Bobby Heins
- 1991: Rick Vershure
- 1992: Bobby Heins
- 1993: Rick Vershure
- 1994: Delroy Cambridge
- 1995: Bruce Zabriski
- 1996: Ron McDougal
- 1997: Bruce Zabriski
- 1998: Bruce Zabriski
- 1999: Bill Van Orman
- 2000: Carl Alexander
- 2001: Dave Fusco
- 2002: Tom Sutter
- 2003: Dave Fusco
- 2004: Frank Bensel
- 2005: John Nieporte
- 2006: Ron Philo
- 2007: Tony Demaria
- 2008: John Stoltz
- 2009: Craig Thomas
| - 2010: Daniel Balin
- 2011: Greg Bisconti
- 2012: Mike Ballo
- 2013: Colin McDade (a)
|